Home›Articles› Every Thanksgiving Dish Ranked by Wine Pairing
Every Thanksgiving Dish Ranked by Wine Pairing
Sir Benedict's Verdict
Ah, Thanksgiving — that delightful time of year when we gather around the table to share our gratitude and indigestion. If you find yourself pondering how to elevate your culinary disappointments with the right wine pairings, fret not, for I am here to guide you through this noble endeavor. Though turkey may sit as the centerpiece, it is often the accompanying dishes that lead us on a tumultuous journey of flavor confusion. With my discerning palate, let us explore the rankings of Thanksgiving dishes, not merely by taste but by their compatibility with wine. Spoiler alert: some pairings are simply better at coping with mediocrity than others.
In the spirit of tradition, we will traverse a veritable cornucopia of Thanksgiving staples, assigning each dish a score and a recommended wine. Perhaps you think cranberry sauce deserves a higher score because it’s crafted with love, or perhaps the ill-fated sweet potato casserole just isn’t up to snuff. Regardless, I’ll attempt to lift the veil on these culinary choices, pairing them with wines that may not salvage the dish but at least offer a comforting companion alongside the inevitable family squabbles.
Ah, the turkey — the star that often steals the spotlight but delivers a lackluster performance. Scored at a respectable 7.5, it finds solace in the embrace of a Pinot Noir, which, much like a supportive friend, compliments the dish’s dry tendencies. The wine’s earthiness and fruity undertones help mask the turkey's occasional blandness, making the experience slightly more palatable. A good choice, but let’s not pretend it’s going to change lives.
Those who relish stuffing know it’s an underrated gem on the Thanksgiving table, scoring a commendable 7.8. The buttery richness of a Chardonnay elevates this dish to new heights, adding layers of complexity that even dry bread and herbs cannot achieve alone. This pairing works harmoniously, making it the highlight of an otherwise forgettable meal. If only other dishes could learn from its example of how to shine brightly amongst mediocrity.
The green bean casserole, a staple that brings a sense of nostalgia tinged with mild disapproval, scores 7.3. Paired with Chardonnay, the creaminess of the casserole is amplified, while the wine’s acidity lifts its rather one-note flavor palate. This combination doesn't exactly set the world ablaze, but perhaps that's the point — it’s comfort food that’s meant to be enjoyed, albeit with a glass of something decent nearby to console you through each forkful.
Ah, pumpkin pie — the sweet finale to our feast that scores a respectable 7.8. Complemented by a Riesling, the wine’s sweetness and hints of spice play beautifully with the pie’s flavors, making this pairing a true triumph. Finally, something that deserves its place on the table! This delightful duo ensures you end the night on a high note, leaving behind the savory disappointments of previous courses.
With a score of 6.7, sweet potato casserole lingers in the realm of ‘why does this exist?’ However, paired with a Viognier, this dish offers a fleeting glimpse of hope. The wine’s floral notes may attempt to elevate the overly sweet concoction, but alas, it is more of a valiant effort rather than a solution. This pairing might salvage the dish for some, but many may still find themselves wondering why they subjected themselves to such a combination in the first place.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
As we navigate this dubious terrain of Thanksgiving delicacies, it becomes clear that not all pairings are created equal. While some dishes, like stuffing and pumpkin pie, find their ideal accomplices, others leave us yearning for something more substantial — perhaps even another bottle. Nevertheless, the key takeaway is this: if you must endure these culinary trials, do so with the right wine in hand. After all, one cannot change the essence of turkey, but a good Pinot Noir may just make it bearable. Cheers to your festive endeavors!
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best wine to pair with turkey?
Thanksgiving turkey, often the centerpiece, can be pairing-challenged. The recommended wine is Pinot Noir, which balances the turkey's dryness with its earthy and fruity notes. This pairing is particularly effective for those who find turkey to be less than thrilling, as it allows the flavors to meld into a more enjoyable experience. Remember, a good wine can elevate even the most mundane of meals.
How can I enhance the flavor of side dishes with wine?
Pairing wine with side dishes can greatly enhance your Thanksgiving meal. For instance, stuffing shines with Chardonnay, which adds buttery richness that complements the dish's inherent flavors. The key is to select wines that either contrast with or complement the flavors of the dish, allowing both to shine. A well-thought-out pairing can turn a simple side into a memorable experience, elevating it from mere filler to something noteworthy.
Are there any desserts that pair well with Thanksgiving wines?
Indeed, when it comes to dessert, pumpkin pie deserves a special mention, as it pairs excellently with Riesling. The wine's sweetness and hints of spice enhance the pie's flavors, creating a gratifying closure to your Thanksgiving feast. Exploring dessert pairings can be a delightful adventure if you choose wines that complement or contrast the dessert's profile, ensuring that every course of your Thanksgiving meal is savored, even if they were lackluster to begin with.
