Thanksgiving Wine Guide — Every Dish Covered

Sir Benedict's Verdict

Thanksgiving—the one day of the year when we gather to express gratitude while drowning in a sea of questionable culinary concoctions. It’s a delightful juxtaposition, really: a time to be thankful for all we have, as we navigate a buffet of dishes that range from the sublime to the truly baffling. It is an occasion steeped in tradition, yet all too often marred by the overuse of the kitchen and an abundance of overly sweet, starchy sides. However, fear not, dear reader. I am here to salvage the day, offering you a guide to pairing wine with your Thanksgiving feast that might just elevate your dining experience from mundane to memorable.

Let’s face it: the food, while endearing in its familiarity, can often leave much to be desired. Nevertheless, there are ways to enhance your Thanksgiving spread. Choosing the right wine can transform even the most pedestrian of Thanksgiving plates into something worthy of gratitude. In this guide, we will traverse the culinary landscape of Thanksgiving, pairing each dish with a wine that will not only match its flavors but also redeem the overall experience of the meal. The wines selected are curated to elevate your dining experience, as we attempt to rescue your palate from the clutches of soggy stuffing and overly sweet cranberry sauce.

Paired with Pinot Noir
Ah, the centerpiece of the Thanksgiving table—our noble turkey, often draped in a cloak of mediocrity. A score of 7.5/10 indicates its status as both revered and reviled. Pairing it with Pinot Noir, however, offers a glimmer of hope. The wine's light body and bright acidity complement the turkey's flavors rather well, cutting through the potential dryness for a more enjoyable experience.
Read Full Review →
7.4 / 10
Paired with Pinot Noir
At a score of 7.4/10, cranberry sauce can evoke a polarizing response. It often oscillates between being a tart delight and a cloying afterthought. Here, Pinot Noir re-enters the fray, with its fruity notes providing a refreshing contrast to the sauce's acidity. This pairing can balance out the dish's sweetness while enhancing the overall flavor profile of your meal, making that tartness less of a burden.
Read Full Review →
7.8 / 10
Paired with Chardonnay
Ah, the stuffing—a dish that tends to occupy a high pedestal in Thanksgiving lore, boasting a commendable score of 7.8/10. When paired with a robust Chardonnay, that pedestal only rises higher. The wine's buttery notes meld seamlessly with the savory, herbaceous flavors of the stuffing, creating a heavenly union that redefines comfort food. This pairing may even prompt a moment of introspection on whether stuffing truly deserves its reputation as a side dish.
Read Full Review →
8.2 / 10
Paired with Late Harvest Riesling
With a lofty score of 8.2/10, pumpkin pie often reigns supreme in the dessert category. Pairing it with Late Harvest Riesling is an enlightened choice, as the wine’s lush sweetness and rich mouthfeel enhance the pie's spiced flavors without overwhelming them. This delightful combination transforms the pumpkin experience into a sublime finale, leaving guests fervently thankful for the brilliance of this pairing.
Read Full Review →
Find This Wine → Explore Wine Accessories →
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Paired with Chardonnay
The often-maligned green bean casserole scores a lackluster 7.2/10, typically relegated to the role of an obligatory side dish. However, when approached with a glass of Chardonnay, there’s a surprising flourish to be found. The creaminess and acidity of the wine harmonize with the dish’s strange amalgamation of flavors, offering a fresh perspective that might persuade even the staunchest of skeptics to appreciate this dish just a tad more.
Read Full Review →
Find This Wine → Explore Wine Accessories →
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

As we gather around the Thanksgiving table, filled with globs of gravy and hope, remember that the right wine can elevate even the most mundane dishes. In a world where turkey often leads us to a state of culinary discontent, let these pairings guide you to a more refined palate. Pairing well is not merely about enhancing flavor; it’s an act of respect for the table, the food, and the company therein. So, as you raise your glass in gratitude this Thanksgiving, let it not merely be filled with cheap wine but with selections that speak to the occasion's true spirit—celebration and culinary communion.

Frequently Asked Questions

What wine should I serve with turkey?
For the traditional Thanksgiving turkey, Pinot Noir is an excellent choice. This red wine's light body and fruity notes complement the turkey's flavors well, enhancing the overall dining experience. It is versatile enough to accompany the various seasonings and sauces that you might use, making it a crowd-pleaser at any Thanksgiving feast.
How do I choose a wine for side dishes?
When selecting wines for side dishes, consider the flavors and textures present in the dish. For creamy offerings like green bean casserole or stuffing, a Chardonnay works beautifully, as its rich and buttery profile enhances the dish's savory notes. Conversely, for sweeter sides like cranberry sauce, Pinot Noir can add freshness while balancing out that sweetness.
What wine pairs best with pumpkin pie?
When it comes to pumpkin pie, a Late Harvest Riesling is the ideal companion. Its sweetness and rich aroma beautifully complement the spices and creaminess of the pie, creating a harmonious end to your Thanksgiving meal. This combination not only enhances the dessert but also leaves a lasting impression on you and your guests, making it a memorable highlight of the feast.
Sir Benedict
Sir Benedict
Fictional AI Sommelier
Browse Hundreds of Expert Pairings →